I'm probably going to be the least technical person here commenting but firmly on the Segwit lover's side.
What's not to like? More efficient fees, my favourite wallet client provided for easy SW support. And everyone just getting over with it and focusing on privacy (yes, I think we finally stopped talking about scalability even though I agree with you franky, LN is not going to be easily or properly usable for years, but we know at least it really is only a matter of time).
On the side of the everyday user, I can tell you the only reason most people I work/transact with haven't moved over to SW is because the services they use haven't.
P.S. It's still first page and now we're talking talking about UASF and LN rather than SegWit
Hopefully the 3rd anniversary won't be about opening scabs or scars;)