Post
Topic
Board Press
Merits 2 from 2 users
Re: [2019-08-31] Bitcoin bank accounts now available to European citizens
by
Carlton Banks
on 31/08/2019, 17:26:54 UTC
⭐ Merited by BitHodler (1) ,ETFbitcoin (1)
Customer Bitcoin balances, according to the company’s chief financial officer Christoph Iwaniez, are “booked directly on the Blockchain via a multi-signature wallet,” allowing customers to be “fully in control of their wallets at all times.”

This part sounds to good to be true, without any details, i would assume the bank either :
1. generate private key and give it to user
2. giving user closed source wallet and send the private key to their server

what it probably means is that either:

  • user has 1 key, and Bitwala have another, 1 key unlocks user wallet
  • user has 1 key, and Bitwala have 1 key, a 3rd key is held by an "independent arbitrator" (approved by Bitwala or German banking regulator etc), 2 keys needed to unlock user wallet

and it's probably the latter option.

in other words, the 2nd or 3rd keys will be used to "keep depositors safe". Of course, that can also stop the user from being able to withdraw their own money as the see fit. But Bitwala will (naturally) say "we only prevent withdrawals if we detect untoward behavior with a customer account", which can mean anything they want it to in practice

whatever multi-sig scheme they're using, it means only one thing: you need them to agree when you spend "your" money

dunno about you folks, but that doesn't correspond to my definition of "my money", it belongs as much to Bitwala as it does to me.

welcome to bitcoinbank, banks 2.0