Hello LoyceV.
I was careful reading your guide, as I am translating it.
Take a look here:
Positive (shown as
+1)
- If you believe someone can be trusted, even when you didn't trade with him, that too deserves positive feedback.
Negative (shown as
-1)
- If you really hate someone and he's a terrible troll, that does not deserve negative feedback.
I know this is like a common practice here in bitcointalk, I know you are not inventing this. But I disagree with those points. Aren't they contradictory?
If you think someone is "cool", so yeah, give him a nice feedback, so everyone think he is trusted and he has a green +1 on his account. If you think someone is a troll, don't paint him red.
Shouldn't both situations have the same approuch?
IMO, both feedbacks, in those cases, should be NEUTRAL.
"Nice guy" or "I hate this troll", as neutral.
There are so many "nice guy" feedbacks with positives trusts here, as there are many "troller' with red feedbacks