What you're doing now is equivalent to me saying that all of you are scammers, and since there are definitely some scammers on Bitcointalk then I'm some "percentage right".
That's the worst analogy I've ever heard and clearly not relevant.
I see it more like... if I cut half my finger off, can I tell people I cut my finger off without being a liar? Absolutely in my opinion.
If you said "whole finger" you'd be a liar though. Similarly, if you didn't have "both sites" in your post you would probably be right, but then RHavar wouldn't have challenged that. Words matter. Context matters. The context was clearly about bustadice vs bustabit.