Fuck this is a shitty situation, its a coin toss for yahoo or the site. Shit, sorry dude this isnt cool.
It really is 50/50 there is a solid case for both sides of this.. personally I believe you should give some and the site should as well.
I dont believe you should of tagged them, I do believe this thread is the best way to get a resolution that suits both parties. Especially with all the bug work you are doing.. fuck this is hard. IMO the site should compensate you as they took the full bet and you couldnt cancel it. On the other hand you knew there were bugs and had been helping, yet as you said if it had lost the site would of told you tough titties
Good PR for the site would be a public settlement and IMO it should be 50% of the total winnings. You win? They win by making it right.
More importantly I dont have the temptation of taking TOAA off ignore seeing all his posts