I agree red trust feedbacks are given too easy now a days around here.
Just want to quote a recent example. I even think this is what OP is concerned about.

Lauda 2019-12-06 Reference Selectively acts as as your "friendly neighbourhood guy", but those double-faced pricks are the worst. Most of what he does nowadays, he does out of spite.
After being called out for his virtue-signalling several times, he tries to attack here and there with half-baked "legitimate concerns".
I wouldn't trust this user nor his judgement with anything.