I hadn't made any conclusions until yesterday.  If you'd have read the thread you would've known that I was open about the fact that I could be wrong.

Right now (as of yesterday) there is enough evidence to prove beyond a reasonable doubt that Og stole BTC144 and I don't need Pirates statement about paying out OgNasty in full to prove it.   (There is evidence that he took more, but it's not strong enough (yet).)


We have pirates ledger for every transaction.
We have ogs thread archived.
We have both Pirates and OgNastys wallets indexed on wallet explorer.
We have the block chain.

Og was receiving weekly interest payments from Pirate, and making monthly payments to his pass through investors.

The last interest payment Og sent to his investors was on August 2, 2012.  

On August 6  Og received an interested payment of BTC66.8
On August 13 Og received an interested payment of  BTC39.2
On August 17 He received a withdraw for BTC38

On Sept 2 he paid out the insurance he had been collecting to 4 investors.  BTC9.92, BTC4.59, BTC22.95 and BTC27.54

We know that was the insurance because Og posted on the same day 'reserves have been paid, pirate has defaulted', and they total BTC65, the same amount Og listed as the 'current reserves' on August 2.

You'll find transaction ids to all of these in the thread if you decide to bother looking into it.