only worth $1,800 at the time
So you want me to find him a scammer, because you cannot trace the blockchain evidence of $1,800 at the time worth of
BTC past a dead end, but he just returned 500
BTC @ $7,500 = $3,750,000 +BCH forks and +++ and he is a scammer?
Come on man. These loaded questions are part of the reason this thread is going to shit.
If you care, just look at the evidence and come to your own conclusion - then try to prove yourself wrong before you try to prove anyone else wrong. If all you've gathered from this thread is that I "cannot trace the blockchain evidence of $1,800 at the time worth of
BTC past a dead end" then I don't know what to tell you.
If you don't care that he stole it because of the value, or that he didn't steal a lot more from theymos, then don't bother.
(btw, I was wrong, it was only worth $1700 - bad math)