Want to know how I can tell that your arguments are breaking down? It's easy; you start to sound a lot like cryptohunter.
You never answered my question. If I am to perform what is arguably a public service of dispute mediation, exactly what do I need to meet your fine and arbitrary standards
I acknowledge that my standards are mine and mine alone, they do not necessarily reflect the position of the forum, forum administration, forum staff, moderators, any other DT1 members. Hell, they don't reflect the thoughts of anyone but me. Got it? Good.
1. Don't be a dick.
2. Don't pad your trust list to boost your own trust score.
3. Don't expect trust list reciprocation.
4. Don't use the trust list for retaliation.
And finally; the only one that really matters:
5. Demonstrate good judgement, good character, and restraint.