A quick acknowledgment that we're not ignoring you all, just busy fixing stuff.
The site runs on an undersized VM so it might be slow at times. Like right now compressing the daily backup seems to have brought it down. Please bear with us until we figure out some of these issues.
We're aware of merit and trust mismatches. Will tackle that over the next couple of weeks. All examples posted in this thread help tremendously, so thank you for that.
From what I've seen, PBIP misses about 1% of all profiles. If you could check the missing ones against
http://loyce.club/usernames/, that would be great

I've found and re-fetched 520 missing profiles. It now seems to be keeping up.
Thanks for all the feedback and keep it coming, much appreciated.