How did this whole "You didn't answer my question! Yes I did!" stuff start?

As far as I can tell, the
full original (unedited) post from Suchmoon displays as
https://i.imgur.com/pyBX4bT.pngSuchmoon simply quoted your questions and then gave a direct "no and no" answer.
From the perspective of a 'popcorn munching observer', it was fairly obvious that Suchmoon believes both your rating and Vod's ratings are "not valid". (And that yourself, Vod and Og need to try being adults for 5 minutes). There doesn't seem to be any ambiguity that I can see.
I'll go sit in the corner quietly now. As you were.