It doesn't look like the OP was dealing with Naster but with some third party. Not sure what's the connection there. Was Naster the recipient of the bitcoins in exchange for those PayPal funds? If so then Naster should pay back the full $725 ("someone else scammed me" is not a valid excuse).
You posted only one screenshot, but you didnt post the screenshot where we decided that I should refund 300 USD to your account what I did. I didnt send you paypal, one customer sent you (and you allowed that!) and he scammed us.
We came to this agreement for following reason: one customer sent many small payments to his account. Few days later, these payments have been reversed by PAYPAL. Trying one more time to solve together this issue, I asked him if he already withdrew the money before this happened. Short story, he moved out already a part and part was left. We agreed that I should get back his paypal account to positive to fix this issue. What I did few days later.
The guy who scammed had sent me around 7-8k paypal balance, almost all has been reversed and I was in short of funds by that time. So it took me few days to send the payment of 300 USD (screenshots following). Normally I have some preventing measures for this by checking few things in accounts of customers, unfortunately these days I had a such overload of work and I missed few checks and this caused me this high loss. And of course, this is not the reason, we just made an arrangement for this case and as always I fulfilled my part.
It could have said "NO, I just dont want you to pay me 300 USD etc.." and I'm very sure I would have fixed the issue with him. Other were affected by this incident and so far nobody complaining here. It should mean what it means.
It's a very simple question. Did you receive $725 worth of Bitcoin from the OP or not?
In this case, I made my part of the arrangement and I will give him nothing more.
The OP posted a few screenshots that show you telling them to defraud PayPal. You paid back only $300 of disputed $725. Both solid reasons for red trust.
You keep repeating yourself. Who said "go and defraud PayPal?" Do you know he was working? Then let me tell you: he gets Paypal funds on his paypal account (he was giving me several accounts to be loaded every day with around 300-400 USD each). Once he had the money, he was simply withdrawing to his multiple bank accounts. Therefore, when this happened, I asked him if he had already moved out the funds so I can see what to do next to fix this ASAP. Just don't sit on one single argument - that you didn't even properly understand - to judge me. Seems you are more excited by your red trust than anything else. If so, Here you go, enjoy you Power to give red trust then.
You both were clearly involved in some shady PayPal shit. It's funny how the part of your conversation after "you already withdrawed ight?" [sic] is missing in your screenshots. That's where you said "better you drop this account I give you an other account free", didn't you? What exactly does this mean? Leaving PayPal holding the bag, right?
It looks like you both were laundering money via PayPal and BTC and you stiffed your "business" partner.
I hope I provided enough information to the community and the mods needed to close this case ASAP.
Mods will not close anything. Scams are not moderated.