Exactly my point, it's the content that matters not the type of feedback in most cases, calling someone a scammer or untrustworthy in green or black font color does not differ much from red, therefore, it makes no sense to say that "oh it's neutral, never mind it".
I'm not itching to do an experiment but I'm quite certain if someone posted "Great member, totally not a scammer" in red it wouldn't be perceived as positive by most users.
At the end of the day stupid ratings reflect poorly on the sender, not the receiver. So I stand by "it's a neutral, who cares", even if it's a stupid neutral.