Bitcoin Core didnt have the easily accessible coin control features back then that it has now. It is a foolish assumption to think that I wasnt sending funds to depositors from change addresses or occasionally online wallets when I was mobile. I had lots of BTC spread all over the place back then as I supported every Bitcoin service I could find. Your ineptitude and incorrect assumptions are what is real.
None of the above relies on where you sent the payments from. It's very clear how much you collected for pirateat, how much pirateat paid you, how much of that you returned to investors, and how much went towards 'insuring deposits'.
You posted the logs.