Bas.....remake the cards/toys free of charge. Now ship them all to everyone with tracking information. Upload receipts and share with minerjones. Ill cover all the costs of shipping which minerjones will pay you after everyone confirms receipt.
This is a reasonable proposal. Let me estimate the time needed.
Yes: Great idea!!!! Grasp on to something very "reasonable" The more complex, the better. Right?
Why don't you grasp onto a real reasonable and straight forward approach, namely: just pay everyone back, and if if any of them wants to reorder, after you have paid everyone back, then take the matter of orders and shipping and all of that mumbo jumbo from there.
Nah. That would be too straight forward. Right?
Instead you want to drag this bullshit out, which should cause a lot of members to be more skeptical about your intentions to make matters good... or that you are even being honest in your description of the purported mess-up.