And all Public Keys start with 1, I feel there is some kind of conspiracy.
/end of sarcasm
I guess you meant addresses ?
Note that a public key is not the same as an address. The public key is being hashed to retrieve the address (sha256 and ripemd160 + checksum).
@OP:
Regardless of the initial statement:
Do not use any website to create a paper wallet. Not even after downloading and running it offline.The
usability is not worth the risk.