Why you want to trust a source if you can use open source wallets where all code is visible ..
Exodus close source, you can't check all code. and op choose exodus wallet already.
Apart from that i think for long term hodling you should use some hardware wallet or paperwallet.
I never heard ethereum have paper wallet like Bitcoin, maybe I am missing something here.
I guess based on the thread of Jollygood the issue is not yet resolved, Exodus is a very safe wallet I'm currently using it and it never failed me,
Maybe you only have small balance.
You can import it to other wallet like Mycellium Wallet. Other coins can also be stored on it.
Mycelium is Bitcoin wallet, how to import erc 20 token when wallet incompatible?