Post
Topic
Board Economics
Re: Marxism theory Suddenly making sense
by
Petryakov
on 07/07/2020, 22:00:01 UTC
Any collectivistic doctrine is doomed to fail, for it contravenes the mere human nature. People are egoistic, which is justified by the law of the evolution. Without proper incentives, a collectivistic society cannot reach full productivity and loses to more efficient models.

• How about , people who are extremely poor are not required to pay the electricity and gas bills for the time being since during pandemic , literally no one has a job , whereas the subsidised bills can be equally divided into the wealthiest class and they be required to pay the same conditioned that it does not take a toll on their monthly income in any way.
[ We are talking about the super poor families here ]

You have just invented a progressive tax system.

• Government needs to standardize minimum income rule in all the regions , be it a small village or be it a big city , people work hard irrespective of the place they work in but there is a huge difference in the salaries.

Nice, a business owner in your village counts a new payroll and concludes that the business is not profitable now, so he:

a) drastically raises prices if the business is locally oriented;

b) shuts down all his operations and moves to a region that provides most marginal efficiency in the other case.

Now instead of people who get smaller wages we have a bunch of unemployed. This can only work properly with public institutions.

•During a job interview priority must be given to person who is most eligible ofcourse but at the same time the next criterion needs to be the economic situation of the family.

How are you going to force employers to follow it? There are many anti-discrimination rules that simply don’t work until you set hard quotas.