You would have traded that 11 btc a million times over
It would depend on the person's finances. If they were well off, they could have sat on that 11 btc.
If a person stole 1,000 BTC from a person five years ago, they owe that person 1,000 BTC today, would you agree?
Mhmmmm. Yeah I would agree. But if the option was to get either 0 of your btc, or the value of the btc at the time in usd. I would pick the latter but I think everyone would.