I prefer a pop up when viewing someone's profile than being redirected to another page.
Personally I prefer to open things like that up in a separate tab rather than have a scroll-over pop-up. Right now, Amazon Prime Video has gone way overboard with features like this, and it's to a point where you really have to watch where your cursor wanders when you've got your hand on the mouse--it's extremely annoying.
I don't think OP's idea is bad at all, but I don't think it's necessary or something that I'd find useful myself. And I can pretty much guarantee that this will find itself in the graveyard of
suggested features that got ignored by TheymosTM.