I Added in post #2, the rest of the text related to this topic.
Who will be the judge and jury for every active member description?
This can create some fuss in the forum and that is not necessarily bad, but I think there will be clash of opinions.
There is a topic created by GazetaBitcoin called Gangs of Bitcointalk that can help maybe:
https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=5226757.0Thanks, about gangs... is just a cult thread. After users have been nominated for each category, public voting begins. The counting of votes can be made absolutely transparent, the results of which will also show who took the second and third places.