I don't know how about Ledger nano but I consider to replace now for Trezor model T since the one is terrible this company is really unprofessional to sell dysfunctional devices.
So after all these problems with multiple trezor one wallets you're still buying trezor T as a replacement? Are you a masochist?
I have ledger nano S and it works fine. If it doesn't you can always use your key words to restore the wallet.
If the problem is with the cables maybe you're bending them or something? My phone charger cables usually break after about 2 years but they're cheap just as usb cables. These things have limited lifespan but you can get them anywhere.