Damn, that's a some serious drama amongst normally rational, reasonable, and respectable folks. I don't know what's lead to this (no references to any of the feedback left or received,) but I hope they can work it out like the rational people they are.
malevolent, Cyrus, and hilariousandco are all listed as moderators on the Collectibles board. Given the wording of the ratings this must have something to do with mods not acting on reports. Perhaps related to Rainbowsky's trollfuckery. I guess that's one way to get admin's attention...