edit: does "the NAS itself" exclude the powersupply? if not sure, you could try your old NAS+drives with the new powersupply, if compattible.
That is good to know! I may have to rely on that, thanks! PSU was the first thing I tested, seems to be fine and putting out the correct power, I'm 99.9% certain the mainboard is toast. Common issue with the Intel Atom CPU on that model apparently