If you are happier with the worse miner and less money, I think no one will miss you here. It's still your decision.
Merry x-mas to all

It's not a question of being happy, it's an observation everyone says that PH or Claymore cheats on sharing but no one really has proof.
I look between my rigs and my pools (I tested 4 pools same things)
9 * RX580 NITRO + SE / 8GB straps
Claymore: 304MHS
PheonixMiner: 302MHS
TeamRedMiner: 294MHS
LolMiner: 294 MHS
We still lose a lot of power from one miner to another. I haven't done the share number test yet.
it's just a shame to fall asleep on optimizations, development of 4GB cards ...
To release a miner without memory optimizations, having to use 50 software for that, claymore was good for that.
Here is an article where they proved that Phoenix miner inflates hashrates by about 3%.