I guess the edge that centralized marketplaces have are consumer and seller protection.
i think it's more that decentralized marketplaces are clunky and not intuitive. consumers wanna quickly navigate to a website or app page to buy something---not download and run an executable file, as is required to use openbazaar. it makes sense for buying/selling illegal drugs and things like that. it makes less sense for buying regular stuff that you can buy anywhere. it's just too much bother.