I was paid by theymos to hold 500 BTC. I returned it when asked along with all the alts theymos asked me to return. He gifted the remainder to me and left me positive feedback.

As I understand it, no one can confirm this except for Theymos? And what coins do you call "remainder"? Or you can go the other way ...
Og is misleading, as usual.
Theymos asked for the coins back, and left OG positive feedback. A lot of lemmings followed. THEN Theymos found out Og had used those coins as if they were his, and declared Og tacky, which according to Og, means he is a disgusting human being.
Theymos did
not leave Og positive feedback for embezzling coins.