Although there are some hardcore exchange users who would be happy with unmanaged markets in football, we believe that it will encourage more liquidity to have managed markets.
I personally don't like unmanaged markets, because I always feel I am very vulnerable due to broadcasting delays, getting distracted etc. And yep, these markets tend to have lower liquidity and are generally pretty wild, so my guess would be that most punters/traders do prefer managed markets. You are just more likely to leave your bets in the markets for a longer time, while with unmanaged markets this becomes more of a hop on hop off thing.