What standards should the ratings uphold?
How would you enforce any such standard?
With 100 members in DT1 the "standard" is essentially what the majority "votes" for with their inclusions. It's slow and inefficient but in the long run it seems to gravitate to some sort of nearly-sane equilibrium, as evidenced by most egregious abusers being excluded, although it also allows old abusers to resurface once the outrage over their actions fades (which might or might not be a good thing depending on your view on forgiveness and all that crap).
~
I can't wait until you try to pull one of your usual stunts on LoyceV... like including someone who red-trusts him. It shall be cringy AF.