Post
Topic
Board Wallet software
Merits 2 from 1 user
Re: Opinions on Phoenix Wallet?
by
LoyceV
on 20/04/2021, 07:38:19 UTC
⭐ Merited by mk4 (2)
Feels like the project is about to close
ACINQ has been around for years. It's much more likely they try to grow and earn billions from an IPO in the future.
Quote
Prob restore it somewhere else on send to a different one
Opening a new LN channel is custodial in Phoenix Wallet. That means you have to wait for it to open before doing anything else.

Meanwhile, Phoenix doesn't show a channel being opened, it shortly showed a new channel as "closed", but that one disappeared. On-chain I can see my transaction is split up into several other transactions already, each with 12 sat/vbyte fee (which is still more than the total fee ACINQ took from my deposit). This was the largest deposit I've sent into LN so far, and channel opening is custodial. I don't know if a channel was opened for me, but if it's with 12 sat/vbyte, it's going to take a while.
Update: I have an open channel! It was opened (with 13 sat/vbyte) a few hours after my deposit confirmed, and a couple hours later the channel and balance became available to me. Here's the interesting part: The on-chain transaction opening the channel isn't confirmed yet! As far as I know, that's not possible!
So, and I'm slightly speculating here, this would mean ACINQ accepts LN-funds coming out of a LN-channel that's not confirmed online yet. Because they're the ones who opened the channel, they can be sure it's not going to be double spent at some point and will confirm eventually. And I also expect their own hub to have confirmed channels with third parties, so third parties aren't dealing with an unconfirmed channel. So far so good, I am quite happy I don't have to wait (weeks?) for this transaction to confirm. But I'm not sure if this means the channel is now more or less custodial: if I try to close the channel, the opening transaction still has to confirm.