Making 435 good reports isn't that hard; it just takes time.  You could probably hit that number in Bitcoin Discussion within a few days if you devoted several hours a day just looking for shitposts.  If you just reported all the garbage in the altcoin ANN section, you could probably get that many good reports in a day.  My point is that being the member with the 37th most good reports doesn't mean a goddamn thing in general and it certainly doesn't have anything to do with this scam accusation.

As far as colires's reputation goes, it's really hard to discern whether he's a serial scammer based on those negs he has that have reference links (and most of them don't).  There's this one, which seems to be just a rage-against-DT neg, while others do have evidence that he really did scam for money.  I'm not inclined to believe untrusted feedback unless there's a valid reference link, but there are enough of colires's negative trusts that do have them that I'm thinking he is indeed a scammer.

I'm going to suspend judgement until he does.  If he can't refute OP's claim, he's getting a neg.