I agree with your opinion. But it seems I'm leaning towards the Nafty scam team
As far as I know, sofico also has a history of poor management (
their service thread). So can't side with one of them.
The two sides are still blaming each other and there doesn't seem to be any compromise.
Actually anyone involved can make accusations including you as a hunter who is harmed. If these two don't provide clarification publicly, then they can be considered scammers. Btw, someone seems to have started uncovering this issue on
Reputations board. Just follow the progress.