Post
Topic
Board Development & Technical Discussion
Re: Is Bitcoin still experimental?
by
n0nce
on 22/09/2021, 17:17:51 UTC
Alright, but even then I wonder who decided on that and why etc., I mean sure it's just a version number, but I wonder how I missed this change completely.. Cheesy
The PR is https://github.com/bitcoin/bitcoin/pull/20223.

I wrote the change, and 12 other developers (including most of the maintainers) ACK'd it. It was also discussed multiple times in some issues and on IRC.

The why is primarily to stop the constant questions of "when 1.0" every time a release is made. Additionally the change aligns the version number with our actual process (we were incrementing the minor version number for versions designated as major releases) and how many people perceive the version number (I see a lot of people who wrote and said the version number without the leading 0).
Interesting. I skimmed the IRC log and it's like 4 people arguing about it for 30 minutes and then the meeting is just ended lol. I get the GitHub approvals but then what's the purpose of the IRC chat, that poor guy's questions about standard versioning method are just ignored basically. I myself like just dropping the 0, it's the easiest and aesthetic choice, but had no issues with keeping the 0 either, I don't think it implies there should be a 1.x eventually.