Also, i don't like the "judge, jury and executioner" approach shown by mtgox.
In what way has mtgox acted as judge, jury or executioner? He came over a heap of stolen money, and blocked the account while the investigation goes on. Would there be any other sensible thing to do? Any other legal options? If mtgox do something illegal here, like releasing the account with stolen funds before the matter is completely resolved, we are all at risk of loosing everything we have on mtgox.
If he has strong , I repeat very strong proof that I am that "thief", so he must go to police and provide that proof to them, and only with police permission he can block money
You can read the proof in this thread. It is damning evidence, and mtgox doesn't need more than that to block your account. In most jurisdictions a bank or exchange has to block the account when stolen money get transferred to it. VISA, MasterCard, PayPal and your bank would do the exact same thing without waiting for the police. They are not allowed to let the thief run away with the stolen money. You claim to have lawyers, but I doubt it.
Still, what MTGOX did is far from lawful/good/just. You see, on mtgox.com page, there are no terms of service, no anti-scam policy, nothing. When users register, they do not agree to anything ! So
mtgox had no damn right to do anythyng, *INCLUDING* any freezing funds !
And not only that, mtgox is not even a fucking bank. So
if Baron is really innocent, and sues mtgox, this will end very badly for mtgox (and possibly Bitcoin's reputation may suffer because of that a little).
Time to look for another exchange i guess ?
Are you telling me you wouldn't take back your own money if you hadn't previously stated that it was your policy to take back your own money?