I think all altcoins will be added in the whitelist. There is always a good reason for something. I think its best that you add specific rules that you want to be added in the whitelist.
I agree, so what I am going to do is add all of the comments so people can see what all of the coins have to offer, some have a more extensive list than others, which may make them more worthy, so,
I think that the way this is going is just fine, everyone that buys digital coin should know about what some people are saying about the coin and the possibility of the coin being dumped like that rather than them having no clue about it,..
This makes people justify the coins they support and lets people see what is so good about them, hopefully they can make the decision on their own so all of this is valuable information for a newb that might just be hopping on an exchange looking for a coin to invest in.
Sure, but if you don't verify these claims people will write anything to make their coin look good. Even a vote system would only lead to the biggest community of bagholders having the 'whitest' coin.
The only way to do this is by doing the research, then making your own choices on what to add to the list and hope the community accepts you as a fair and reasonable arbiter of shitcoinery.