Those times aren't in order or you've got the dates wrong infact, must be both, can you check and put in chronological order and I'll try to piece together what would have happened.

Or gimme the the receive address and I'll look on the explorer, will be able to give definite answers then.

EDIT. Nvm, it's theone in your sig. Gimme a few.

Ok, so the 1250 you sent took the 1266.562614 & 1262.643457 and rolled them into the 2500 output leaving 29.106071 as change as can be seen here
BTW, it looks like you've just minted the 1067.62727 @ 2014-03-23 14:18:01 see your address