Yes the Gateway should be set to 192.168.168.1 and PC set to 192.168.168.100
When connecting a miner to a PC I don't think there is any gateway involved, he should just set the IP address on and the sub netmask on the PC
Have you tried just directly connected the miner to the PC? Assuming the LAN cable is a crossover type (most are) it should work.
In fact, the majority of LAN cables are straight-through,but that doesn't really matter since most devices nowadays can be connected using both straight-through and crossover since these new network interface controller can negotiate the parameters regardless of the connection type.
only change the miner to use DHCP, save then reboot it.
Doesn't Avalon have an option to reset to DHCP using a physical procedure of some type? this seems like a lot of work just to get the miner to DHCP.
It just doesn't make any sense why DHCP won't work to connect to pools. I suppose it could be the controller or hashboards themselves
Unlikely, it's more likely to be a network-related issue, if you want, I can try to troubleshoot it for you via anydesk, you can PM me.