Two things that I failed to understand:
1. You guys clear your inbox? Why? You use that email address both for personal and crypto so you need to keep them clean? It's personal preference though, so I can't comment further, just curious why bother cleaning your inbox.
2. Not even 1 tx proof, or screenshot or anything, left in your possession? Alltily indeed asked a deposit confirmation email, but the way I see it, that's not necessarily all 1,118 deposits. They just ask for an email showing that the address --a static, non-changing address that they dedicate for you-- is yours. One is enough.
If I may add a third one, is the PhoenixCoin platform has a fund history? Like a proof showing a token successfully mined or moved somewhere? If they have, maybe you can use that.
As for HodlerCompany, would a screenshot of tx history from the sender side --suppose there is any-- sufficient? What about a signed message from the sender address like what ph4nt0m had tried? It's a valid ownership proofing method that's even acknowledged by this forum. If your aim is just to have a proof that some address is belonged to someone, I think thats a proof of ownership enough
P.s.: oh, and last, coinman76 stop spamming
1) I always keep my inbox clean and constantly delete old emails. I have a maximum of 5 important emails in my inbox. I have such a habit, I like cleanliness and order.
2)see last post by ph4nt0m. This is the only and correct solution for both parties, but Altilly stubbornly offered only 1 type of evidence in the form of screenshots, as they knew that the vast majority would not be able to provide them and it would be possible not to make returns. Altilly does not want to agree to the option proposed by ph4nt0m, as this will set a precedent and thousands of deceived users who have been denied refunds by Altily will demand them. It is very good that this situation has come up for public discussion and now it will not be possible to quietly hush up the situation.