Oh, my bad, I thought that you guys wouldn't be stupid enough to let other people generate your keys directly for you. My mistake. What idiot pays someone else that has a copy of their private key?

Don't be stupid, the keys are made piecewise so that YOU are the only person with they key. I have been using a key from them and I have no problem with it, talk to ThePiachu, he runs the site. If somebody stole money from you it's entirely your fault.