I agree of what you are saying. Theres nothing wrong about asking a question and i think that is normal for a newbie to ask because he dont know how to do the analysis. Sometimes we need help and suggestions for others in order for us to learn something or to become knowledgeable. And thats the number one strategy that we need to gain before doing/making an investment.
Anyone has the right to ask and anyone has the right to give an answer that is in accordance with what he already knows, regardless of whether the questioner has understood it or not, what is clear is that everyone has the right to ask questions and has the right to give answers to all questions.