Any chance that it's actually a "SecurePrint™" backup instead of unencrypted (just edited)?
What are the colors of Armory's logo in the paper backup? Green+Blue or Red+Blue?
No it's 100% an unecrypted backup, it says it right at the top of the page, it has the armory logo and all the data I gave above. I'm very confused why it doesn't seem to work.
How about the logo's color?
It's important because the former is an indication that it's a Regtest/Testnet paper backup while the later means that it's for mainnet.
The former wont restore the same Wallet ID using that tool and it is essentially worthless aside from testing purposes.