Second, the fact that Bitcoin is finite doesn’t by itself make it a value. Scarcity does not determine whether something is a value or not. Scarcity only determines the price of something that is already determined to be a value because of another reason. For example, certain forms of toxic waste may be scarce but that doesn’t mean the waste is a value.
You are wrong.
Certain form of waste is scarce? If scarce, that means people are demanding for it, which makes the waste useful and it will be costly because of the demand for it.
If you meant this, you also meant that the law of deamnd and supply is wrong, which means you only want to change part of economics to your own idea of wrong.