But when a user's feedback leaving is (1) clearly out of retaliatory, (2) clearly to hostage others to silent against him, (3) clearly based on inappropriate arguments, (4) clearly using it to scam others would you still add him in your trust network or you will tilde (~) him?
No I wouldn't, and that's why I ~'ed JollyGood and a number of other members.
The trust system (including both the DT aspect and feedback giving in general) is just straight-up broken and is way too complicated and full of holes to work as anything people can rely on. That's not a new opinion from me; I've been saying the same thing for years, but people always defend it. Who knows, maybe I'm the one who's wrong.
But what's the point of this thread, exactly?