But we are at least in agreement about something (HURRAH!) with regard to shorting: I don't participate in that market either, not so much for the reasons you stated but that it seems morally wrong to profit from the failure of a market (I remember the Soros-short inspired sterling crash of the eighties).
All this moral crap really annoys me. Shorting helps to prevent selloffs from being so severe, because shorts cover on the way down and provide buying demand.
Moralists always cause the opposite of what they portend to.
Successful trades buy low and sell high. They dampen market fluctuation, increase stability, and are in my view the most moral of all.