I think you should prioritize only good and trusted casinos in this list so that new users and all existing users can choose a casino site without hesitation.
That's the idea. However, you should never blindly trust any information you see without doing your own research to check if the site can still be trusted with your money. One that is good today can tomorrow go rogue and start scamming users. I don't check the reputations regularly to know everything that is happening. I make decisions when I see something bad in the scam accusation board or when a user informs me about something negative going on.