1. Votes for inactive users will not be taken into consideration anymore. The event is related to the activity made by users during current year and not for the past.
So is posting (or logging in) in 2022 enough? Or is there a minimum number of posts required?
2. No merit sending is allowed from nominees to users which nominated them.
This should reduce the drama involving votes. Just to be clear: the way it's written now you're counting all Merits sent to any of the users. I assume this only counts for the voting-topic, right? Otherwise Merit sources will end up at around -500 votes.
We were also curious about how users feel about implementing a rule which would give chances to more people to win. What we were thinking about is the following: to arrange things thus the winner of a category cannot be the same person from previous contests. Or he can be, as this does not mean a ban -- but he can be with more efforts. To be more precise, all previous winners could start with a coefficient of 0.8. Attention! -- this happens only regarding the previously won category!
This is tricky. It feels like my opinion on this is a conflict of interest, but I agree to the points made here:
I appreciate I am heavily biased here given I have previously won the same category twice, but I wouldn't take this approach. You could easily end up in the situation where someone is deemed to have won, but someone else would have won the "popular vote", by getting more votes which were each worth less. I can already picture the arguments which could arise, particularly if there will be prizes involved. It is also disincentivizes people from voting for the previous winner, since their vote will be less valuable than if they voted for someone else. I would either go down the route of excluding previous winners or doing nothing at all.
You must have 50 earned merits to vote
This feels too restrictive to me. I would have opted for a lower number, say 20 earned merits, but that's just me.
See
this list: 2924 users received 50 Merits, 5632 users received 20 Merits. And for some of those "received" doesn't mean they "earned" it.