I don't know if that was his biggest mistake with Casino Critique or not (since I have no idea how it's going), but I'm going to play devil's advocate here and say that even though he concealed his identity for a while, there was still no scam happening. 

And that's kind of the reason I'd always respected you as a valued member of the community.  Maybe some members have a better grasp of what happened with Bitlucy, but I did read your thread on it and it definitely didn't sound like you were out to join in on some scam that they were pulling off.  Apparently a lot of people here do, though, which is why you've been getting such harsh treatment since then.

My suggestion is to roll with it, no matter how bitter it makes you feel, because memories can sometimes be short and people can be redeemed with time and the right actions.