What about the winners from the "negative" category like Fail of the Year or Antihero? they will be nominated because of something bad they did, can they get rewards for something that most users have condemned as wrong?
According to
Wikipedia, an antihero is not necessarily the 'opposite of a hero'. There is no 100% definitive definition either, though, but we did get a small definition in the OP!
In my opinion, for such a contest (and because there is a price to win), think about
'main character in a story who may lack conventional heroic qualities and attributes'; I'll be looking for a user who is doing valuable contributions to the forum and / or Bitcoin in general, while lacking some 'conventional heroic attributes'. In this forum's context that could be maybe having a bad (hard to understand) writing style, bad English skills, not being very active or also being a shitcoin supporter. Such a user could still provide great value to the forum and not qualify for other categories.