if you look at history this year we should have achieved recovery according to the information i read out there as well on this forum, usually after the bear market will enter a period of price recovery, they say experienced people this year is the right time to buy a lot
If we'll try to look at the price point of the last bull run, we haven't recovered yet.
But if we'll look to the time that it should have recovered by now then we can say that the bear is starting to be gone eventually. So, the bad news is that this type of recovery hasn't been seen yet and bitcoin's price is still under $20k.
Honestly, the price that it has gotten now have become more stable and got less volatile.