⭐ Merited by Foxpup (6) ,DdmrDdmr (4) ,Welsh (4) ,n0nce (3) ,GazetaBitcoin (3) ,Halab (2) ,Pmalek (2) ,ETFbitcoin (2) ,Daniel91 (2) ,Rikafip (1) ,turtlecute (1) ,joker_josue (1) ,Lillominato89 (1) ,creep_o (1) ,Charles-Tim (1) ,hymperion (1) ,Coin-1 (1)
I have recently been congratulating a new user on the italian board for his astonishing Merit/Post ratio. This particular user is a well known expert user in the italian community, and already provided good content here on the forum, where hes new. So this ratio is quite expected. As hes pretty new to the forum, he asked me what is a great merit/post ratio?.
This is something it resonated with me, as he very first thread I opened here on the forum was on a very similar subject:
I think the idea ha some value, so I decided to leverage @ddmrddmr merit dashboard and try to figure out something.
Bitcointalk Merit Dashboard
I did the following steps:
The following table is the output
If you click on the above graph you will be redirected to the interactive
If you are wondering who those outliers are, have a look at the TOP 50 (excuse me for my poor formatting capabilities):
I think filtering them a little bit the outcome can clear out a few not-too-relevant outliers. So I filtere the results using the following criteria:
Only 85 users satisfy those strict criteria.
There are three exceptional users, who stand out from the crowd with a ratio above 8.
Some users are well above 4, a level it is incredibly hard to achieve!
Also for this latest extraction, which is the most significant, in my opinion, here you have a direct table for your convenience (excuse my poor formatting capabilities)
You can play yourself with the spreadsheet I used looking at this link:
Spreadsheet Link
This is something it resonated with me, as he very first thread I opened here on the forum was on a very similar subject:
Hello,
I am quite new to this board, so I am trying to provide the best post I could as I find the merit system a good way to raise the signal/noise ratio.
I accidentally bumped in a user with over 1k posts and almost the same merit.
Is there a way to have a ranking of best user sorted with high ratio?
Time is even scarcer than bitcoin, so I want to effectively use my time to learn from user that posted quality stuff using effectively their time!
Thanks,
F1
I am quite new to this board, so I am trying to provide the best post I could as I find the merit system a good way to raise the signal/noise ratio.
I accidentally bumped in a user with over 1k posts and almost the same merit.
Is there a way to have a ranking of best user sorted with high ratio?
Time is even scarcer than bitcoin, so I want to effectively use my time to learn from user that posted quality stuff using effectively their time!
Thanks,
F1
I think the idea ha some value, so I decided to leverage @ddmrddmr merit dashboard and try to figure out something.
Bitcointalk Merit Dashboard
I did the following steps:
- downloaded the entire forum population from @ddmrddmr dashboard from the User Summary Tab
- filtered out banned users
- filtered out "brand new" members
- computed the ratio between received merits and
- setup other filters on post, merits and ratio
- sorted the users according to descending Received Merit/Post ratio
The following table is the output
If you click on the above graph you will be redirected to the interactive
If you are wondering who those outliers are, have a look at the TOP 50 (excuse me for my poor formatting capabilities):
I think filtering them a little bit the outcome can clear out a few not-too-relevant outliers. So I filtere the results using the following criteria:
Code:
Posts>100
M/R>1
Banned=N
I filtered out some relevant users (your truly merit rascal included). But I think the graph is much neater: M/R>1
Banned=N
Only 85 users satisfy those strict criteria.
There are three exceptional users, who stand out from the crowd with a ratio above 8.
Some users are well above 4, a level it is incredibly hard to achieve!
Also for this latest extraction, which is the most significant, in my opinion, here you have a direct table for your convenience (excuse my poor formatting capabilities)
You can play yourself with the spreadsheet I used looking at this link:
Spreadsheet Link